Back
Medical, Health & Aged Care

Cataract surgery fee lottery leaves some patients paying six times more than others for the same procedure

Australian Health Funds Council

Australians undergoing routine cataract surgery face vastly different medical bills, with typical fees at some private hospitals more than six times those at many others, new data from the Australian Health Funds Council (AHFC) reveals.


The analysis of privately insured cataract procedures performed in 2024-25 found:

• at 70 of the 122 private hospitals examined, the typical (median) out-of-pocket medical cost was $500 or less;
• at 10 hospitals, the typical cost exceeded $1,750; and
• the highest typical costs were at St Vincent’s Private Hospital Sydney at $3,034.

The figures cover combined out-of-pocket fees charged by the eye surgeon and anaesthetist for a standard, single-eye cataract procedure. They are not fees charged by the hospitals.

The findings are in AHFC’s submission to the House of Representatives inquiry into access to and affordability of medical specialists, which recommends reforms to improve fee transparency, strengthen billing protections, and give patients greater choice in their medical care.

AHFC CEO Dr Rachel David said patients should not be paying up to six times more for the same procedure when there was no evidence that higher-charging specialists delivered better outcomes.

“This variation in fees is difficult to justify. Patients should not face dramatically different costs for the same procedure when there is no evidence that higher fees deliver better outcomes.

“I worry that some people are taking out loans or raiding their super to pay these sorts of fees because they don’t know there are other surgeons and anaesthetists charging much less.”

AHFC’s analysis also found substantial variation in surgeons’ out-of-pocket fees for other common procedures in 2024-25:

• the median fee for a knee replacement was $1,080, with 10% of patients charged more than $5,300;
• the median fee for a hip replacement was $1,240, with 10% charged more than $5,500;
• the median fee for gall bladder removal was $600, with 10% charged more than $2,410; and
• the median fee for children’s tonsil removal was $850, with 10% charged more than $2,210.

Dr David said with specialists’ fees rising three times faster than inflation, there was no way consumers, Medicare and health funds could keep up with the price increases. For health funds, paying specialists more for their hospital services means increasing the cost of health insurance premiums.

“We need to put downward pressure on specialist fees so more Australians can afford to see a specialist when they need one. We cannot expect taxpayers and people investing in health insurance to be chasing this hyperinflation.”

Dr David praised the Albanese Government’s plan to publish more specialists’ fees on the
Medical Costs Finder website, but said patients needed more information about specialists’
charges much earlier in their healthcare journey. They should not be expected to find it
themselves.

“If your GP refers you to a specialist, you should receive fees for a range of specialists in your area, including some in the closest capital city if you live in a rural or regional area, so you can choose a suitable, affordable specialist,” she said.

The AHFC submission also recommends:


• banning hidden administration and booking fees, split billing and surprise charges,
backed by enforceable penalties;
• making informed financial consent legally enforceable, with advance written estimates
covering the total expected cost of treatment, including fees from the surgeon,
anaesthetist and other providers wherever reasonably practicable;
• protecting patients from undisclosed out-of-pocket charges for non-emergency
treatment;
• integrating specialist fee information into GP referral software, so patients can compare
costs before booking;
• improving patient choice through open referrals, easier access to second opinions and
longer referral validity periods; and
• considering Medicare bulk-billing incentives for initial specialist consultations to reduce
financial barriers to care.

For planned procedures, the AHFC recommends specialists provide financial consent
information at least seven days before treatment, or within two days of booking when surgery is arranged at shorter notice.

“We are hearing about far too many people getting surprise bills, including bills from
anaesthetists the day before their surgery, or on the day of surgery,” Dr David said.

“We need a system that helps GPs and patients compare options, makes the full cost clear
before hospital treatment, and protects people from undisclosed charges.

“The current inquiry is a great opportunity to make specialist care more affordable and give
Australians greater control over their healthcare decisions.”


Contact details:

Julia Medew [email protected] 0402 011 438
Andrea Petrie [email protected] 0412 655 26