Cutting Migration Is A Sugar Hit We Can't Afford
OpenCorp
- Property investment firm OpenCorp warns that bluntly cutting migration without regard to skills risks a three-stage cycle: an initial drop in housing demand, followed by stalled construction projects and job losses, then a return to shortage when migration inevitably rises again.
- OpenCorp argues that reducing migration could hit recent first-home buyers hardest, using the example of a buyer with a 5% deposit on an $800,000 home who would fall into negative equity if prices dropped by just 10%.
- Beyond housing, OpenCorp highlights that cutting migration would worsen Australia's ageing population challenge, with Treasury projecting the ratio of over-65s to working-age Australians rising from 28% to 39% over the next 40 years, increasing the tax burden on remaining workers.
- OpenCorp is calling on the Federal Government to make building trades Tier 1 visa priority, placing construction workers at the front of the skilled migration processing queue — a position echoed by the Housing Industry Association.
- Alongside targeted migration reform, OpenCorp is urging a stronger local trades pipeline through TAFE and apprenticeships, incentives for experienced tradies to mentor apprentices, and stable long-term migration settings to allow builders to plan beyond the election cycle.
Australians are being told fewer migrants means cheaper homes. Property investment firm OpenCorp says that's only half the story.
Migration has become a contentious issue, especially topical in the lead-up to the 28 November Victorian state election. Federal Opposition Leader Angus Taylor has pledged to cut net overseas migration to 100,000 a year. One Nation wants to go further.
OpenCorp Director of Investments Michael Beresford said migration isn't the enemy. Getting the mix wrong is.
"Cutting migration is a sugar hit. Everyone pats themselves on the back. Then the real problem starts," Mr Beresford said.
OpenCorp says a blunt cut, made without regard to skills, risks playing out in three stages.
-
The high. Demand drops fast. The housing shortfall appears to shrink almost overnight.
-
The crash. Builders lose buyers. Projects stall. Jobs go. Prices may dip, and the most recent buyers feel it first.
-
The hangover. Governments realise they still need workers and lift migration again. But many tradies have left the industry, and the shortage returns with fewer people to fix it.
"You can't fix a housing shortage by sending home the people who build houses," Mr Beresford said. “First home buyers on small deposits will be hit hardest if prices fall. The sword falls on the last through the door," he said.
As an example, a buyer who put a 5% deposit on an $800,000 home has $40,000 in it. If that home drops 10% to $720,000, the deposit is gone, and they owe more than it's worth.
"Someone who bought ten years ago can ride that out. Someone who bought last year, on a stretch, can't," Mr Beresford said.
Tradies are next. Construction is one of Victoria's five biggest employing industries, and its spending flows well beyond the building site.
"When homes are being built, everyone's got a job. The trades, the truck drivers, the curtain makers, the white goods stores, the furniture shops," Mr Beresford said.
Renters feel it last. Fewer homes started today mean fewer rentals down the track.
There's a second cost no one is talking about. Treasury's new Intergenerational Report, released in September, projects the ratio of over-65s to working-age Australians will rise from about 28 per cent to 39 per cent over the next 40 years. In Treasury's words, that pressure will be "primarily borne by working-age Australians".
"Fewer workers paying for more pensions, aged care and health care means a bigger tax bill for the ones left," Mr Beresford said.
"Cut migration hard, and that bill lands on Victorian families. Nobody's selling that side of the story."
Construction made Canberra's visa priority list in September. But it shares that list with healthcare, teaching, resources, agriculture and more.
OpenCorp doesn't back any party. Its argument is about who gets in first. They are calling on the Federal Government to make building trades Tier 1 entry immediately. That means first in the processing queue for tradies applying from here and overseas.
It also wants Victoria's next government, whoever wins on 28 November, to push Canberra to make it happen.
The call echoes the Housing Industry Association, which has said construction workers should be at the front of the skilled migration queue.
"Construction made the priority list. That's a start. But when everything's a priority, nothing is," Mr Beresford said.
He admits the policy isn't in a property investor's own interest.
"More builders means more homes, and prices that rise more slowly. That's not great for property investors. But it's what the country needs."
OpenCorp is also calling for:
-
A stronger local trades pipeline through TAFE and apprenticeships
-
Incentives for experienced tradies to stay on longer and mentor apprentices
-
Steady migration settings, so builders can plan beyond the election cycle
"Cutting migration is the easy bit. Living with the hangover is the hard part."
-ENDS-
About us:
OpenCorp is an Australian property investment company founded in 2006 by Cam McLellan, Matthew Lewison and Allister Lewison. For more than 20 years, OpenCorp has helped everyday Australians build wealth through property, combining independent research with full transparency, publishing the performance of its entire client portfolio against ASIC disclosure standards. OpenCorp has helped clients build more than $2.5 billion in property portfolio value, with a track record of outperforming the capital city average by more than $351,000 per property since 2006.
Contact details:
Ashleigh Dyer - AD Press Office
0421128914
[email protected]