Back
Government- NSW

Rule of law concerns in Mount Pleasant Mine Bill

Law Society of NSW

Media Release

Thursday, 19 November 2026

Rule of law concerns in Mount Pleasant Mine Bill

The Law Society of NSW is concerned that clause 17 of the Mount Pleasant Mine Bill 2026 (NSW) risks undermining the rule of law.

President of the Law Society of NSW Ronan MacSweeney said that clause 17 of the Bill, an example of a Henry VIII clause, which permits the relevant Minister broad powers to modify or override any Act of Parliament by regulation.

“Such a process risks reducing the transparency and predictability of the law and weakening parliamentary oversight. We are concerned that this could set a dangerous legislative precedent. If provisions of this kind were to become commonplace, there would be a risk of increasingly complex interactions between primary and delegated legislation, with potentially far-reaching or unintended consequences, including for the rule of law,” Mr MacSweeney said.

“While the Government is free to enact legislation authorising a particular development to proceed notwithstanding the operation of existing laws, cl 17 of the Bill goes substantially beyond what is necessary to give effect to the stated objects of the proposed legislation.

“In the Law Society’s view, sufficient flexibility in relation to the conditions applying to developments of this kind is already provided for by Part 4 of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW).”

For these reasons the Law Society suggests the removal of cl 17 from the Bill; or at a minimum, further amendment to more clearly define the instances when the Minister is permitted to exercise power under cl 17, and to provide for adequate oversight mechanisms if this power is sought to be exercised.

Media contact
Damien Smith | Director, Media and Public Relations

The Law Society of New South Wales
M: +61 417 788 947
E: [email protected]

Attachments

101126 Law Society of NSW - Rule of law concerns in Mount Pleasant Mine Bill.pdf

Download